Pickerel Lake

About Pickerel Lake

Pickerel Lake enjoys close proximity to Petoskey while also serving as the beginning of the Famous Inland Waterway.

The Inland Waterway “begins” in the serene waters of Pickerel Lake, a small body of water that is large on style and substance. Despite measuring at just over 1000 acres itself, Pickerel Lake allows access to endless nautical travel, with the Great Lakes accessible directly from these waters. Pickerel Lake is a relatively shallow lake, but does reach depths of 60-70’ in its center. Pickerel Lake also lives functionally as an extension of Crooked Lake, connected by a channel commonly referred to as the “Black Hole”. Pickerel Lake is particularly convenient in its access to Petoskey, with downtown just 15-20 minutes from much of the lake.

Pickerel Lake Real Estate at a Glance
Total Listings 3
Average Price $549,667
Highest Price $999,000
Lowest Price $275,000

Scroll down to see Pickerel Lake homes for sale, or keep reading about Pickerel Lake real estate and other important information about the area.

Browse Pickerel Lake Real Estate Listings

All Listings $200,000 - $300,000 $300,000 - $400,000
$900,000 - $1,000,000

Browse Pickerel Lake Real Estate Listings

3 Properties Found. Page 1 of 1.
Photo of Listing #468066

6650 South Beach Drive, Alanson

$999,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,300 Sf

MLS® # 468066

Photo of Listing #466867

Parcel B South Beach Drive, Alanson


MLS® # 466867

Photo of Listing #466868

Parcel A South Beach Drive, Alanson


MLS® # 466868

For full access to Pickerel Lake real estate listings, including the ability to save searches and receive email updates, register with Kyle Lieberman today!

Discover Pickerel Lake Homes For Sale

The listing inventory on Pickerel Lake is typically quite low, resulting directly from the modest lake size. Homes that do come available typically range $350,000-700,000. However, occasionally an exceptional listing will come available, and price points can climb as high as $800,000 to over $1,000,000. Many of the more desirable offerings on Pickerel Lake can be found in the Eagle Beach Association, located just off M-68. Trail’s End & Township Park are both also highly popular lake section along the southern shoreline. There is a wide range in home styles, from rustic summer cottages to clean, modern designs. There are a number of available vacant lots in the $150,000-350,000 range, making new builds a more affordable option on Pickerel Lake versus other Northern Michigan lake markets.

Pickerel Lake is not as heavily developed as many of its fellow Northern Michigan lakes. Large sections of the western shoreline are owned by the Michigan Department of Natural Resources. A significant amount of the eastern water’s edge is operated as Camp Petosega, one of the area’s preferred lakeside camping destinations.

Most Pickerel Lake residents identify Petoskey as their hometown, with dining and shopping reasonably accessible. However, for those located on the northern shoreline, Alanson is just a 5-10 minute drive while Indian River can be reached in about 15 minutes. Pickerel Lake is home to a healthy blend of seasonal and year-round residents. The more affordable prices make this an attractive area to buy in and rent seasonally to capture a return on investment. The more accessible price point also keeps carry costs down such as taxes and mortgage payments, making Pickerel Lake real estate a strong contender for the value-savvy buyer.

Life on Pickerel Lake

As part of the Inland Waterway, Pickerel Lake affords an endless array of boating destinations. Residents can pull away from their dock and ride all day without exploring the same shoreline twice! Two full service marinas are a short ride away on Crooked Lake, ensuring your boat is ready for long days of fun on the lake. Pickerel Lake also boasts an impressive fishery, with numerous other wildlife species visiting throughout the year! Pickerel Lake is a true natural beauty, and the perfect destination for anyone longing for peace and quiet.

Buying on Pickerel Lake oftentimes requires an inside track on forthcoming listings or willing sellers not currently marketing their properties. Because the Pickerel Lake inventory is small, buyers need every advantage possible to get in front of new offerings before anyone else. I am very tuned into this market with experience representing buyers and sellers on Pickerel Lake. As you peruse Pickerel Lake homes for sale, let me know if something interests you. When you are ready to dive deeper into Pickerel Lake, please call me at (231) 622-1535 or contact me by clicking here.

Additional Pickerel Lake Real Estate Information

Emmet Association of Realtors (Northern Michigan MLS) LogoThe data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the Northern Michigan MLS (NM-MLSX). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Kidd & Leavy Real Estate are marked with the NM-MLSX logo and the detailed information about said listing includes the listing office. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor Kidd & Leavy Real Estate shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. Northern Michigan MLS, Inc © All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.